Written by Damian Cranney
‘Winning by Design’, a report published at the end of last year by the Irish Department of Business, Enterprise and Innovation, references over 40 different variants of design. The list is inspired by the ‘disciplines of user experience’. Analogous to the challenge of defining a big word like design, Dan Saffer’s work seeks to map the etymology of ‘User Experience’ – for some, an equally nebulous term.
This year, Beltech’s theme is ‘Design in Tech’. Giving prominence to design and its growing role in the technology ecosystem is no better sign of how far we’ve come in Northern Ireland business. But our struggle to define what we really mean by ‘design’ is an indicator of the important work yet to be done.
In a recent exchange with Beltech’s curators, I listened to an experienced software lead from Kainos tell me about the rich engineering ecosystem we’re now known for in Northern Ireland. “But if we’re going to create products that can make a genuine impact in the world”, she said, “…we now need do the same for design”. I’m paraphrasing, but it was music to my ears.
Defining design isn’t easy… In Northern Ireland, enlightened businesses have just about figured out that user experience is mission critical, even though many struggle to untangle ‘UX’ and ‘UI’ or simply don’t care. For the record (and in my opinion), the former is a set of methods for designing better software, the latter is the point of interaction itself.
A mentor once told me that companies don’t want design, they want solutions to the problems they’re struggling with. It stayed with me. Design happens to be the best discipline I know that can address gnarly business problems as well as unlock opportunities for growth. So ‘design in tech’ puts the design paradigm into technology, offering a new perspective on how to launch products and services that prioritise users, customers, people – and their messy realities. Whilst technology is the great enabler, there is no design without people. When you think about it… if every inanimate thing we can see and touch has been ‘designed’, then design is fundamentally an expression of the human experience (… that’s Steve jobs, not me).
The debate rages on about what design is and how to do it. In a recent flurry of social chatter, Natasha Jen, Partner at celebrated design firm Pentagram argued ‘Design Thinking is Bullshit’. A headline-grabbing address delivered by a classically trained designer that, for me, missed the fact that designers aren’t terribly good at defining what design is, nevermind ‘design in tech’. It took a mechanical engineer called Dave Kelley to convince the business world about the value of design. He launched Stanford University’s globally acclaimed d.school and a little company called IDEO – now one of the world’s largest design firms.
Great design is a team sport – an output of inspired and diverse teams, not an individual pursuit. No one definition or checklist can accurately define what it is, although most of us can recognise it when we see it. So rather than add to the debate, a more useful exercise might be to describe the aspects of great design that show up consistently when design and technology are considered as two sides of the same coin.
As a sort of combined homage to Dave Kelley’s ‘Ten Faces of Innovation’ and MIT’s ‘Essential elements of design’, these are my nine aspects of great design (or considerations for better-integrating design into our businesses).
Design has a massive role to play in the realisation of Northern Ireland’s economic potential. So I hope that Beltech can kick-start a conversation about how we can grow through a better understanding of ‘design in tech’. By no means definitive, my list sets out the aspects of great design that can be enabled by technology. But to realise our potential, I believe businesses in Northern Ireland need to:
MIT Alum and current head of inclusive design at AutoMattic, John Maeda has documented design in tech’s growth over the past 4 years in his ubiquitous report. So the conversation is unlikely to go away anytime soon. As Tim Brown said in his TED talk all the way back in 2009, design got small in its preoccupation with style, but now ‘design is big again’. I would go further as to predict that design’s future will be shaped by its relationship with technology. And economic growth will be linked to how best we can embrace both.